Therapy
What AI Therapy Can't Replace: Real Human Relationships
Megan Murphy, Expansive Cofounder
Table of Contents
AI Therapy: Helpful or Harmful
The Role of Real Human Connection
Friction, Growth, and Healing
Isolation vs. Thriving in Relationships
We don’t really know what life will look like as AI continues its massive transformational growth. Already, there are apps that will text you and act as your therapist. Maybe you’ve tried this already.
If you are someone who gains a lot from studying alone, taking advice, and challenging yourself to make changes on your own, these tools might be very helpful. And let’s face it — they are also cheap.
And! There are studies coming out showing the risks of using a chatbot as a stand in therapist.
The Relationship is Key
My experience in therapy—both as a client and as a therapist—is that the key ingredient for healing is the relationship itself. Now, my ChatGPT friend can feel very relational! In fact, it’s probably much better at giving me exactly what I want in a frictionless environment than any human relationship could. But isn’t it the friction that we need to work through?
We are humans who come from human parents, and most of us have issues related to other people and relationships in our lives that we are working with and through.
In-person therapy is more challenging because we are real, and we often don’t give each other exactly what we want. We project onto each other, and we push each other’s buttons. But nothing compares to someone witnessing and sharing your pain. This won't feel the same with a chatbot.
In my lifetime, I won't be isolated with a chatbot. I’ll be with people I love, people who challenge me, and people I don’t know at all. I want to be okay, I want to thrive! in all of these scenarios.
Fighting Isolation
Do you remember the deep pandemic days when people started to feel rusty at relationships? We were all spending so much time at home—many of us alone and isolated. While this can feel safe sometimes, ultimately, it isn’t what we need, at least not all the time.
Babies who aren’t given the physical and emotional attention they need fail to thrive.
Fail to thrive. Think about that.
Human Connections and the Necessity of Real Relationships
You know what it’s like to sit in front of your computer or with your face in your phone. And you know what it feels like to be with another person.
So, thriving is exactly what I’m talking about. In this incredible journey of life on Earth, don’t we want to flourish? For most of us, this doesn’t include being alone in the woods. It’s about being with other people. Therefore, learning to sharpen your skills in navigating relationships is worth every bit of the time you invest.
Want more content like this?
Join our mailing list
Book Your Intro Session With A Therapist
Find A therapist